Saturday, December 3, 2011

FDI: Angel or Demon?


Till a few days back my mind was in a state of flux as far as the issue of FDI was concerned.  My mind ran here and there to pick up the best argument available around, whether it was in support of this new policy or against it did not matter to me. Every time I heard somebody speak on it, a part of my understanding got puzzled, but at the same time, a lot more got clearer. My present situation is that of a journalist, who is generally expected to know a bit of everything. Whether it’s a good/angel or bad/demon thing, only time will spell out…
    Now, how do we understand this new policy of FDI in retail sector? To be precise and specific, 51% in multi-brand and 100% in single brand? One of the best ways to understand is to jot down the negatives (angels) and positives (demons) and see which weighs heavier. It is commonplace that a policy is adopted only when its benefits are much bigger than its detriments.
            Employment, infrastructure, technology- these are the benefits of opening retail market to Foreign Direct Investment, as the government and the advocates of this policy have been reiterating. The counter argument that is being put forward is that it will wipe out the ‘mom and pop’ shops from our society. To this, those batting for the team called FDI have to say that India is such a country that it has the ability to accommodate both megastores and small retail outlets, firstly and secondly, it’s only allowed in cities with minimum population of 10 million, so saying that it will kill kirana stores does not hold any truth.
   Another stream of argument is that companies like Walmart have such way of working that they leave behind not only ethics but also human values.
   What has been bothering me for the last few days is this question: Can’t India create employment and build infrastructure on its own? Also, why FDI has not been allowed in defense and aviation sector which are much in need? I don’t have facts and figures with the help of which I can say that India has the capital to build cold storages and create employments, but I refuse to believe that only this can bring the benefits that have been associated with FDI.
     A superficial analysis of the retail market suggests that it has been working at a decent pace and does not seem to have any systemic problem, whereas if we look at the aviation and defense sector, the problems are staring at our faces. If we talk about defense sector, India does not have state-of-art equipments; it does not have the system with which it can repair its old instruments and equipments; 70% of its military equipments are imported; only 30% are indigenous. Allowing FDI here will not only strengthen our military capabilities but also Defense Pubic Sector Units (DPSU). Also, the problem of technological and capital help will get sorted out.
  Aviation industry, which has been suffering from systemic problems, is in much need of FDI. Though Kingfisher episode had sparked debate on this issue, not much could happen. A look at the aviation sector and one can say that all the Indian airlines currently functioning, except, I guess, Jet Airways, are incurring heavy losses. It’s not that it’s a recent phenomenon and they are in loss due to increasing prices of jet fuel and all that. The systemic flaw which this sector has needs to be solved through policy change that includes opening of this sector to FDI.
 A quick look at aviation, defense and retail shows that the government has touched that sector which has been functioning properly and not done much about the other two which have been perennially in bad shape and structure. 
  What is disturbing is not the fact that retail has been opened but the fact that not much has been done in other two spheres. Can one go one to the extent of saying that all this has been done under the pressure of the United States of America and to suit the business aspirations of the western world? Can one also ask: should not a country like India, which claims to be one of the fastest developing nations, keep its own aspirations and goals way ahead of others (nations)?
   Any Indian can say with surety that India has the capital and the power to generate employments for its citizens and to build cold storages where perishable food products can be stored- the two most important benefits/angels of FDI.
   In the present scenario, it does not seem that the government is in any mood to roll it back. In fact, it does not need to because the benefits/angels, as they look in the present context, are many and detriments/demons less. I think the floor of India should be opened to let the angels and demons fight so that we the Indians can see who comes out victorious! 

No comments:

Post a Comment